Student-athletes listed are first team all-Americans. In the case of Swimming and Diving and Track and Field, competitors have to place in the top eight at nationals to earn all-American status.
Baseball
- 1982--Bob Varner
Men's Basketball
- 2005--Travis DePree
- 2006--Brandon Crawford
Women's Cross Country
- 2016--Jessica Shaw
Football
- 1940--Walter Ptak
- 1958--Tom Taylor
- 1976--Steve Spencer
- 1986--Joe Felton, Mike Grant
- 1991--Hank Wineman
- 1993--Ron Dawson, Jeff Brooks
- 1994--Chip Heyboer, Jeff Robinson, David Lefere
- 1995--David Lefere
- 1996--Jason Carriveau
- 1998--Jason Carriveau, Pat Slone
- 2000--Keith Debbaudt
- 2011--Chris Greenwood
Women's Soccer
- 2001--Stacey Supanich
Men's Swimming and Diving
- 1991--Steve Cohen
- 1993--Erik Scollon
- 1994--Chris Behling
- 1995--Ed Weber
- 2005--Dan Fradeneck
- 2007--Paul Krone
- 2016--Jake Burris
- 2017--Nate Kozycki, 400 freestyle relay (Sebastian Tostado, Derek Bosko, Parker Belmore, Len Ciemniecki)
- 2018--Nate Kozycki
Women's Swimming and Diving
- 1984--Sue Leiby
- 1995--TerryAnn Evelyn
- 1997--Molly Maloney
- 2007--Lindsay Brown
- 2009--Emily Magyar
- 2010--Emily Magyar
Men's Track and Field
- 1981--Tim Hartson, Cameron Owens, Tracy Garner
- 1982--Tracy Garner, Steve Meads
- 1983--Tim Hartson, Tracy Garner, Albion Relay (Vernon Wilson, Pat Blakley, Gary Allore, Tim Hartson)
- 1986--Dan Pekrul
- 1987--Dan Pekrul
- 1988--John Dunlop
- 1989--Scott Newsome, Lance Coleman
- 1990--Lance Coleman, Doug Goudie
- 1991--Lance Coleman, Steve Gilbert
- 1992--Steve Gilbert, Tom Reason
- 1993--Steve Gilbert, Tom Reason
- 1994--Tom Reason
- 1999--John Bennink, Pat Slone
- 2001--John Bennink
- 2002--Nick Morgan, Jared Owens
- 2003--Ivan Meiring, Nick Morgan
- 2004--Ivan Meiring, Nick Morgan
Women's Track and Field
- 1984--Kathy Dec
- 1985--Kathy Dec