Baseball
3rd Team -- Richard Fabian, 1983 (3B); Tyler Millward, 2011 (OF)
2nd Team -- Mike Jehle, 1996 (DH)
1st Team -- David Lefere, 1997 (SS)
Men's Basketball
1st Team -- John Nibert, 1979
Women's Cross Country/Track & Field
2nd Team -- Cassie Vince, 2019
Football
2nd Team -- Eric Baxmann, 1992 (LB); Kyle Klein, 1996 (QB); Nick Gates, 1998 (DB); Nick Gates, 1999 (DB); John Bennink, 2001 (WR); C.J. Carroll, 2012 (DT)
1st Team -- Brice Drogosch, 1982 (LB); Michael Grant, 1986 (DB); Scott Bissell, 1990 (DB); Eric Baxmann, 1993 (LB); Jeff Shooks, 1993 (P); Jeff Shooks, 1994 (P); David Lefere, 1995 (DB); David Lefere, 1996 (DB); Andrew DiFranco (OL), 2016
Softball
3rd Team -- Cynthia Weisenauer, 1988 (OF); Megan Russell, 2003 (OF); Megan Russell (OF), 2004
2nd Team -- Christie Cleland, 1996 (IF)
1st Team -- Karen Hale, 1983 (P)
Men's Soccer
3rd Team -- Chris Himes, 2005 (M), Andrew Prince, 2016 (D)
Women's Soccer
3rd Team -- Elizabeth Hermiller, 2001 (M); Laurie Vance, 2002 (M)
Men's At-Large
1st Team -- Chris Behling, 1994 (Swimming); Neil Forster (Tennis), 2007
2nd Team -- Joe Silvestri, 2015 (Men's Lacrosse)
Women's At-Large
2nd Team -- Wendy Lombardi, 1984 (Track); Christie Cleland, 1996 (Soccer)
1st Team -- Sue Leiby, 1984 (Swimming); Emily Arend (Tennis), 2002