Most Points/Season: 126, Virgil Petty, 1997
Most Points/Career: 271, Andrew Fabry, 2015-2018
Most Touchdowns/Game: 5, Dustin Louwaert vs. Tri-State, 2004; Virgil Petty vs. Olivet, 1997
Most Touchdowns/Season: 21, Virgil Petty, 1997
Most Touchdowns/Career: 44, Jeff Robinson, 1991-1994
Most Rushing Touchdowns/Game: 5, Dustin Louwaert vs. Tri-State, 2004; Virgil Petty vs. Olivet, 1997
Most Rushing Touchdowns/Season: 21, Virgil Petty, 1997
Most Rushing Touchdowns/Career: 39, Jeff Robinson, 1991-1994
Most Receiving Touchdowns/Game: 4, Justin Thomas vs. Eureka, 2019
Most Yards Rushing/Game: 306, Clinton Orr vs. Alma, 2009; 256, Dustin Louwaert vs. Tri-State, 2004
Most Yards Rushing/Season: 1,629 (307 atts.), Hank Wineman, 1991 (9 games)
Most Yards Rushing/Career: 3,912, Clinton Orr, 2009-2012
Most Rushing Attempts/Game: 49, Dave Egnatuk vs. Olivet, 1970
Most Rushing Attempts/Season: 307, Hank Wineman, 1991
Most Rushing Attempts/Career: 583, Hank Wineman, 1988-1991
Most Consecutive 100-Yard Rushing Games: 18, Hank Wineman 1990-91
Most Receiving Yards/Game: 284, Chris Barnett vs. DePauw, 1996
Most Receiving Yards/Season: 995, John Bennink, 2001
Most Receiving Yards/Career: 2,534, Chris Barnett, 1993-1996
Most Receptions/Game: 16, Brian Spencer vs. Hope, 2012; Tyler Sykes vs. Hope, 2016
Most Receptions/Season: 77, Zach Brigham, 2014
Most Receptions/Career: 179, Brian Spencer, 2009-2012
Most Touchdown Receptions/Season: 17, Justin Thomas, 2019
Most Touchdown Receptions/Career: 28, Chris Barnett, 1993-1996
Most Pass Attempts/Game: 55 (28 completed), Steve Wasil vs. Hope, 2003
Most Pass Attempts/Season: 388, Dominic Bona, 2015
Most Pass Attempts/Career: 1,234, Dominic Bona, 2012-2015 (764-1,234)
Most Completions/Game: 39, Dominic Bona vs. Hope, 2014
Most Completions/Season: 255, Dominic Bona, 2015 (388 atts.)
Most Completions/Career: 764, Dominic Bona, 2012-2015 (764-1,234)
Most Passing Yards/Game: 466, Kyle Thomas vs. Franklin, 2018
Most Passing Yards/Season: 3,313, Steve Wasil, 2005
Most Passing Yards/Career: 8,824, Dominic Bona, 2012-2015
Most Passing Touchdowns/Game: 6, Kyle Thomas at Franklin, 2019; Dominic Bona vs. Aurora, 2014; Travis Rundle vs. Olivet, 2000
Most Passing Touchdowns/Season: 34, Dominic Bona, 2015
Most Passing Touchdowns/Career: 84, Dominic Bona, 2012-2015
Most Interceptions/Game: 5, Mike Montico at Olivet, 1991
Most Interceptions/Season: 16, Jon Vigi, 1980
Most Interceptions/Career: 41, Jan Firek, 1987-1989
Best Completion %/Season: .671, Kyle Klein, 1996 (151-225)
Best Completion %/Career: .619, Dominic Bona, 2012-2015 (764-1,234)
Most Total Offense/Game: 542 (466 pass, 76 rush), Kyle Thomas vs. Franklin, 2018
Most Total Offense/Season: 3,521 (2,976 pass, 545 rush), Dominic Bona, 2015
Most Total Offense/Career: 9,629, Dominic Bona, 2012-2015 (8,824 pass, 805 rush)
Longest Run From Scrimmage: 97 (TD), John Lessway at Wabash, 1996; Chris Hohlbein vs. Wilmington, 1995
Longest Pass From Scrimmage: 93, Chris Barnett from Kyle Klein vs. DePauw, 1996; Brian Blanzy from Kyle Thomas vs. Olivet, 2018
Longest Kickoff Return: 99 (TD), Jared Owens vs. Hope, 1999
Longest Punt Return: 95 (TD), Jim Bell vs. DePauw, 1969
Longest Punt: 83, Jeff Shooks at Alma, 1994; John Massab vs Adrian, 1980
Longest Field Goal: 52, Andy Cline vs. Tri-State, 2004
Longest Field Goal Attempt: 62, Steve Moffatt vs. Hope, 1987
Longest Interception Return: 105 (TD), Frank Joranko vs. Ashland, 1950
Longest Blocked Punt Return: 46, Sean Brogan at Mount Union (NCAA Playoff), 1998
Longest Pass With Lateral: 52, Bob McDonald from Ced Dempsey from Frank Joranko vs. Wilmington, 1951
Longest Free Kick Return: 75 (TD), Tim Riendhl vs. Olivet, 1978
Most Punts/Game: 12, Brian Hearns at Olivet, 2007
Most Punts/Season: 63, Tyler Hunter, 2002
Most Punting Yards/Game: 432 (10 punts), Kirk DeFrenn vs. Hope, 1999
Most Punting Yards/Season: 2304 (61 punts), Brian Hearns, 2007
Best Punting Average/Game: 55.2 (6 punts), Jeff DeLosh vs. Wabash, 1981
Best Punting Average/Season: 40.5, Brandon O'Connell (32 punts), 1998
Most Blocked Kicks/Career: 4, Lin Reed, Jr., 1955-58 (2 punts, 2 PAT's)
Most Punts Blocked by Opp./Game: 3 vs. Wooster, 1971
Most PAT Kicks/Game: 11, Mike Zacha at Alma, 1996 (11-11)
Most PAT Kicks/Season: 61, Andrew Fabry, 2015 (61-68)
Most PAT Attempts/Season: 68, Andrew Fabry, 2015 (61-68)
Best PAT %/Season: 1.000 by four players, Andy Cline (25 of 25), 2003; Keith Debbaudt (36 of 36), 2000; Scott Visser (5 of 5), 2000; Jesse White (19 of 19), 1974
Most Field Goals Made/Half: 3 (4 atts.), Brandon O'Connell at Butler, 1998
Most Field Goals Made/Game: 4, (4 atts.) Cody Lehman at Hope, 2013
Most Field Goals Made/Season: 13 (14 atts.), Keith Debbaudt, 2000
Most Field Goals Made/Career: 40 (55 atts.), Andy Cline, 2001-2004
Most Field Goals Attempted/Season: 18 (12 made), Andy Cline, 2001
Most Field Goals Attempted/Career: 55 (40 made), Andy Cline 2001-2004
Most Tackles/Game: 29, Paul Elder vs. Olivet, 1986
Most Tackles/Season: 189, Steve Spencer, 1976
Most Tackles/Career: 406, Steve Spencer, 1974-1977
Most Tackles for Loss/Season: 23, Pat Slone, 1998
Most Quarterback Sacks/Season: 12, Pat Slone, 1998
Most Fumble Recoveries/Game: 4, Tom Taylor vs. Hope, 1958
Most Fumble Recoveries/Season: 14, Tom Taylor, 1958
Most Interceptions/Season: 9, Mike Grant, 1986; Tom Myers, 1969
Most Touchdowns From Interceptions/Season: 2, Chris Greenwood, 2009; Dan Bzura, 1987
Most QB Sacks/Game: 5, Scott Ammons vs. Hope, 1988; C.J. Carroll vs. Olivet, 2011
Most Consecutive Games Started/Career (non-kicker/punter): 39, Ron Dawson, 1990-1993; Mike Montico, 1990-1993 (includes post-season)
Most Consecutive Games Played/Career: 43, Jeff Shooks, 1991-1994 & Mike Zacha, 1993-1996 (includes post-season)
Single-Season Passing Leaders
Steve Wasil 3,113 yards (2005)
Dominic Bona 2,976 yards (2015)
Dominic Bona 2,674 yards (2014)
Kyle Thomas 2,435 yards (2018)
Dominic Bona 2,308 yards (2013)
Kyle Klein 2,226 yards (1996)
Kyle Thomas 1,899 yards (2017)
Spencer Krauss 1,841 yards (2011)
Jan Firek 1,775 yards (1988)
Jake Wilson 1,766 yards (2006)
Travis Rundle 1,761 yards (2000)
Spencer Krauss 1,753 yards (2010)
Single-Game Passing Leaders
Kyle Thomas 466 yards (vs. Franklin, Sept. 8, 2018)
Spencer Krauss 434 yards (vs. Kalamazoo, 2011)
1,000-Yard Rushing Seasons
Hank Wineman 1,629 yards (1991)
Clinton Orr 1,396 yards (2010)
Jeff Robinson 1,305 yards (1993)
Mike Czarnecki 1,304 yards (2015)
Jeff Robinson 1,264 yards (1994)
Hank Wineman 1,200 yards (1990)
Colin Parks 1,163 yards (2015)
Bill Barker 1,136 yards (1989)
Mike Czarnecki 1,119 yards (2014)
Virgil Petty 1,111 yards (1997)
Dustin Louwaert 1,100 yards (2004)
Clinton Orr 1,051 yards (2011)
Gabe Cooper 1,048 yards (1992)
Dave Egnatuk 1,028 yards (1970)
Single-Game Rushing Leaders
Clinton Orr: 306 yards vs. Alma (11/14/09)
Darrin Williams: 249 yards vs. Kalamazoo (10/13/12)
Clinton Orr: 245 yards vs. Hope (10/30/10)
Clinton Orr: 241 yards vs. Hope (10/15/11)
Mike Czarnecki: 240 yards vs. UW Stevens-Point (9/5/15)
Clinton Orr: 234 yards vs. Hope (10/16/10)
Darrin Williams: 211 vs. Olivet (11/2/13)
Mike Czarnecki: 208 vs. Kalamazoo (10/11/14)
Doug Freeman: 206 vs. Concordia, Ill. (9/15/18)
Clinton Orr: 205 vs. Trine (11/12/11)
Albion's MIAA Most Valuable Players
1938: Ordell McElhaney (E)
1951: Frank Joranko (DB)
1952: Bob Wikstrom (RB)
1953: Fritz Shurmur (C)
1958: Tom Taylor (E)
1961: Joe Shurmur (OG/LB)
1963: J.B. Elzy (OB)
1965: Ron Springer (OG)
1966: Barry Siler (DE)
1970: Dave Egnatuk (RB)
1976: Steve Robb (QB)
1977: Steve Spencer (DT)
1984: Dan Korson (LB)
1985: Lance Brown (RB)
1986: Mike Grant (DB)
1989: Bill Barker (RB)
1989: Scott Ammons (DT)
1991: Hank Wineman (RB)
1992: Mike Montico (QB)
1992: Kris Knobloch (DT)
1993: Jeff Robinson (RB)
1994: Jeff Robinson (RB)
1994: Todd Morris (RB)
1994: Jim Davis (LB)
1995: Robert Taylor (DL)
1996: Kyle Klein (QB)
1996: Jason Beglin (DL)
1998: Pat Slone (DL)
2000: Ben Gitler (LB)
2003: Glen Brittich (LB)
2004: Dustin Louwaert (RB)
2005: Steve Wasil (QB)
2011: Clinton Orr (RB)
2011: Chris Greenwood (DB)
2012: C.J. Carroll (DT)
2015: Dominic Bona (QB)
All-Time Series Records vs. MIAA Rivals
| Opponent | Series Started | Series Record | 2019 Result |
| Adrian | 1906 | Albion 59-30-1 | W, 69-24 |
| Alma | 1900 | Albion 64-50-4 | L, 32-28 |
| Hope | 1926 | Albion 45-39-7 | L, 52-33 |
| Kalamazoo | 1896 | Albion 92-37-5 | W, 37-17 |
| Olivet | 1884 | Albion 88-25-6 | W, 30-21 |
| Trine | 2003 | Tied 10-10 | W, 24-14 |
| Finlandia | 2018 | Albion 2-0 | W, 54-6 |
Records do not include post-season contests, unless specifically noted (per NCAA ruling)